Exposing the Real Che Guevara and the Useful Idiots Who Idolize Him
Humberto Fontova
Penguin Group
Death of a Revolutionary: Che Guevara’s Last Mission
by Richard Harris
W.W. Norton
Reviewed by Mayanna Allen
Every now and then I like to peruse the biography section of the library. I now know more about Zsa Zsa Gabor than any of my friends or family. Last month I happened upon a whole shelf of books about Che Guevara. What I knew about him I gleaned from bumper stickers and t-shirts. I picked two books whose authors seemed to hold differing opinions.
Exposing the Real Che Guevara and the Useful Idiots Who Idolize Him by Humberto Fontova draws a clear line in the sand before the reader opens to page one. Fontova outlines Che Guevara’s participation in the killing of political dissidents during and after the revolution in Cuba. He is quite graphic in his descriptions and uses quotes from survivors of that era. He makes a strong case for Mr. Guevara being a blood thirsty super turd.
My problem with this book is the preaching to the choir tone about it. Fontova uses witty and nasty lines like “Revolutionary Ringo Starr…” page 34, to push his point. If I had started out with a strong pro Che opinion I would not have made it past the title, making the whole book a little redundant. But, as per the success of Michael Moore and Nancy Grace, I guess the choir likes a good sermon.
By comparison, Death of a Revolutionary: Che Guevara’s Last Mission By Richard Harris is written in a more diplomatic tone. Richard Harris tells the story of Che Guevara’s last mission in Bolivia. He does a wonderful job of sketching the larger political situation at hand at that point in history. Harris obviously has a better opinion of Che Guevara than Humberto Fontova. He skips the death camp in Cuba almost entirely. Harris does however point out Guevara’s failings as an organizer in Africa as well as in Bolivia. He also gives the reader a full picture of Che Guevara’s married life without passing judgment, something I had a hard time doing.
As far as getting the whole picture on the Elvis of guerilla warfare, I think I will require more reading. Humberto Fontova’s book felt too full of rant and spite for me to trust him. It was kind of like reading talk radio. Harris, on the other hand presented me with a great read, and some new facts.
Mayanna Allen is a daring reader of all things. Magazines, signs, minds, books of all sorts and on occasion, (with great reluctance) directions. She has read books in thirty two states and three continents. She lives in Portland Oregon with her husband and two small children. Visit her new blog, Mothermayi.
Recent Comments